Valentine Heart Gummies

This year, I’ve made Valentine heart gummies just for you! They’re heart-shaped, delicious, and they also happen to be good for you.

Valentines Gummy Hearts | Fed and Fit-1

There were two three “holidays” that I REALLY loved in grade school. In no particular order, my favorites were {are?}:

1. Bike Rodeo Day. Tell me you had bike rodeo day! It’s the one day us single digit-aged folk got to show off our bike skills in front of the WHOLE school. The day I went sans training wheels on the skinny long stretch was probably one of the best days of my life.

2. Battle of Flowers Day. Now this one I know is probably specific to Texas, if not San Antonio alone. Battle of Flowers Day is part of the Fiesta celebration! There’s a big parade downtown full of floats decorated with {you guessed it} TONS of flowers. To prep for the big day, we made our own float for the school mini parade. Thinking that I was somewhat of a tissue paper flower wiz, I was always very eager to show mine off.

3. VALENTINES DAY! This one probably wins. I LOVED Valentines Day! Still do, in fact. Sure in college I got caught up in the “ugh, Valentines Day” grumble with the rest of the 20 year old girls but I’m proud to say that I’ve fully recovered. Back when life was extremely simple and extremely significant {I’ve noticed those two often go hand-in-hand}, Valentines Day involved each student turning a shoebox into their own personal decorated mail box ready to collect all the sweet little notes from classmates and teachers. We’d spend the night before the big day writing notes to all our classmates with special stickers for our best friends or secret crushes.

Valentines Gummy Hearts | Fed and Fit-2

I still like to give out Valentines. I think they’re sweet, unexpected, sometimes misinterpreted, but mostly heart warming.

Valentines Gummy Hearts | Fed and Fit-3

Valentines Gummy Hearts | Fed and Fit-4

Just a little baggie of 5 hearts is enough to say, “I love you so much that I want you to enjoy a little tasty, fun to eat treat that also happens to be good for you.” Amen.

Valentines Gummy Hearts | Fed and Fit-5

These Valentine heart gummies are really simple {and fun!} to make. For the layered look that I went for, you’ll need to prep a few days in advance. You could also just mix all the layers together for one solid color. Whatever makes you happy makes me happy!

Valentines Gummy Hearts | Fed and Fit-6

Let’s get to preppin’ …

Valentines Gummy Hearts | Fed and Fit-7

The star of our Valentine heart gummies is the oh-so seasonal and oh-so tasty grapefruit juice! I worked for the nicest man during my last few years of college who would bring me barrels of Texas grapefruit.

Valentines Gummy Hearts | Fed and Fit-8

Pour 1 and ¾ cup {6 oz} of grapefruit juice in a small saucepan. If you’re not a fan of the stove and love your microwave, you could also just use a microwave-safe dish!

Valentines Gummy Hearts | Fed and Fit-9

While your grapefruit juice is heating on the stove or in the microwave, measure out your grass-fed gelatin. THIS is the kind I use – make sure you buy the orange type.

Valentines Gummy Hearts | Fed and Fit-10

To make Valentine heart gummies, I recommend 1 Tbl of gelatin for every cup of liquid. If you’re going for the layered look, add 3 Tbl of gelatin to the 1 and ¾ cup of grapefruit juice. Add it to the simmering or hot juice and whisk until dissolved.

Valentines Gummy Hearts | Fed and Fit-11

Honey time! While the honey is optional {especially if you’re on a sugar detox}, it gives these candies a nice sweet touch.

Valentines Gummy Hearts | Fed and Fit-12

Add an equal amount honey – 2 Tbl for the 1 and ¾ cup juice or just 1 Tbl for each cup of liquid.

Valentines Gummy Hearts | Fed and Fit-13

Whisk until well combined.

Valentines Gummy Hearts | Fed and Fit-14

Line a rimmed baking sheet with parchment paper.

Valentines Gummy Hearts | Fed and Fit-15

Pour your juice, honey, and gelatin mixture in!

Valentines Gummy Hearts | Fed and Fit-16

Spot any bubbles?

Valentines Gummy Hearts | Fed and Fit-17

Pop ‘em! Then stick that sheet in the fridge for 2 hours or overnight – you want it set.

Valentines Gummy Hearts | Fed and Fit-18

Gus is tired of all this valentine/gelatin talk and would like to take his new prize outside for an emergency yard planting.

Valentines Gummy Hearts | Fed and Fit-19

Feel the gelatin to be sure that it’s set.

Valentines Gummy Hearts | Fed and Fit-20

Coconut milk is the star of our next layer!

Valentines Gummy Hearts | Fed and Fit-21

Prepare it exactly the same as you did the grapefruit juice: 1 can of milk with 3 Tbl gelatin and 2 Tbl of honey.

Valentines Gummy Hearts | Fed and Fit-22

Once it’s heated and whisked together, pour it over the first layer and set in the fridge.

Valentines Gummy Hearts | Fed and Fit-23

Wait 2 hours or overnight until set.

Valentines Gummy Hearts | Fed and Fit-24

Prepare the final layer exactly as you did the first! Pour it over the coconut milk layer and refrigerate for an additional 2 hours or overnight.

Valentines Gummy Hearts | Fed and Fit-25

All finished! I can’t wait for the unveiling!

Valentines Gummy Hearts | Fed and Fit-26

Grab yourself a cute little heart cookie cutter {this is a good option: Fox Run Heart Cookie Cutter Set, 5-Piece}. Mine is about 1” across.

Valentines Gummy Hearts | Fed and Fit-27

Start cutting into the sheet pan to release your Valentines hearts!

Valentines Gummy Hearts | Fed and Fit-28

How cute is that?

Valentines Gummy Hearts | Fed and Fit-29

Keep cutting!

Valentines Gummy Hearts | Fed and Fit-30

I recommend grabbing the cake pop plastic bags for collecting these goodies. About 5 each tied with a ribbon is the perfect size!

Valentines Gummy Hearts | Fed and Fit-31

So tasty. I hope you love them!

Valentine Heart Gummies

Prep Time 5 minutes Total Time 0:05 Yields 100 gummies
0.0 rating


  • 3 1/2 cups or 28 oz. fresh grapefruit juice
  • 1 can coconut milk
  • 9 Tbl gelatin
  • 6 Tbl honey {optional}


  1. Layer 1: heat the grapefruit juice and whisk in 3 Tbl gelatin and 2 Tbl honey. Pour into a parchment paper-lined rimmed baking sheet. Let set in refrigerator for at least 2 hours or over night.
  2. Layer 2: heat 1 can of coconut milk with 3 Tbl gelatin and 2 Tbl of honey. Pour over layer 1 and let set in refrigerator for at least 2 hours or over night.
  3. Layer 3: repeat step 1 and let set over night.
  4. Using a 1" heart cookie cutter, cut the gummies out. Place 5 to each bag and tie with a ribbon. Keep refrigerated.
  5. Enjoy!



13 Responses to “Valentine Heart Gummies”

  1. #
    Steph Dposted February 10, 2014 at 11:26 am

    You are ADORABLE– I wish I was in your life so you would give me one of these bags! LOL.

  2. #
    Nadia Washlickposted February 26, 2014 at 2:54 am

    These are so lovely! I will definitely be making them next year (maybe with strawberry puree!).

  3. #
    Laurieposted September 12, 2014 at 12:08 pm

    So, first of all, you may want to double check your recipe list- it states that 3 and 1/2 cups of juice is 16 oz. That is incorrect. One cup is 8 fluid ounces, so 3 1/2 cups would be 28 ounces.

    I made these today, and they tasted really nice, but did not have enough gelatin to be stable enough to put in candy bags, or pack for on the go snacks. I had to melt it down again, and add one more tablespoons of gelatin to each layer. Then they were pack-able.

    • #
      Cassyposted September 12, 2014 at 2:23 pm

      Right you are, Laurie! Thank you so much for the helpful comment! I’ve updated the post. Glad you liked the gummies!

  4. #
    Kathleenposted October 8, 2014 at 12:34 pm

    How long can you keep these in the refrigerator? I can’t wait to make them!

    • #
      Cassyposted October 10, 2014 at 2:49 am

      I keep mine about 5-7 days, if they last that long. Enjoy!

  5. #
    Annposted December 3, 2014 at 8:12 pm

    Getting ready to make these and I was wondering if you’ve ever tried using silicone molds instead of cutting them out individually? Thanks!! Yuuummm!!

    • #
      Cassyposted December 4, 2014 at 8:13 pm

      I haven’t, but I imagine that they may work great! I’d love to know how the come out.

  6. #
    getmelyricsposted May 24, 2016 at 8:53 am

    We Introduce you our new Songs Lyrics Website.Here you can search all kind of pakistani and indian lyrics songs on this website.

    Songs Lyrics

  7. #
    Nanciposted February 11, 2017 at 6:49 pm

    I agree with Steph D- I want tobe your friend so I can be on the receiving end of this yummy idea! Thanks for the post!

    • #
      Cassyposted February 13, 2017 at 3:08 pm

      Ha! <3

  8. #
    Allisonposted March 27, 2017 at 7:34 am

    Hi Cassy!

    Can you make your gummies (specifically talking about the recipe from your Fed and Fit book) with frozen fruit? Is there a reason you prefer using fresh fruit?

    • #
      Cassyposted May 2, 2017 at 6:07 am

      You can use frozen fruit! Just make sure it defrosts 🙂

Leave a Comment

As Seen On...